It isn’t over yet

Democratic Representative Nick Milroy of South Range in northwestern Wisconsin was trying to retrieve some clothes from his office in the Capitol Thursday night when police tackled him and arrested him for trying to enter the building.

Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker thinks he has won in his battle to squash the public employee unions and slash public safety net programs.

The problem for him — and the hope for the rest of us — is that he violated open meeting laws, and perhaps a few others. Unless the courts are as corrupted by corporate America as he seems to be, the law can not be upheld.

Video of the meeting shows Rep. Peter Barca, the Assembly Minority Leader, pleading throughout that the meeting was illegal, that he hadn’t even been given a chance to read the law.

But none of this is about law; this is about seizing control of the state and subverting laws for the financial gain of the wealthiest. It’s about getting rid of the middle class because it’s such a bother to these corporate-owned clowns and allowing people like the Koch brothers to control America.

They already control the private sector. We have watched the unions there lose power and the workers’ benefits and real wages fall. Look at the ads on TV about help with crushing debt and “underwater” mortgages, payday lending and car-title loans. These are the equivelent of the company store, where workers couldn’t possibly get out of debt because necessities were more than the workers’ weekly wages.

Studies have shown that it takes from two to three times minimum wage, and sometimes more, to eke out a living in any city in America. Those figures don’t include such things as eating out, cable TV or other entertainment.

This is the real agenda, to take American workers back to the days of the robber-barons of the Industrial Revolution.

Gov. Walker gave away the same amount in tax breaks to the wealthy that he’s demanding back from state workers and poor people in cuts to wages and safety-net programs.

We all need to get behind the workers, do what we can to protest, to fund the reccall elections, to get the word out that this kind of illegal bullying will not be tolerated in our America, because if we don’t, we will have lost the last vestiges of our America to the corporations and their allies.

We made a difference

Health care advocates from across North Carolina filled the gallery this morning when the NC House Health and Human Services Committee met to consider House Bill 115, a bill that would hand over the control of the state’s health insurance exchange to the insurance companies and their allies.

They had a bit of the deer-in-the-headlights look as they saw the gallery filled to overflowing. There wasn’t even any standing room.

As of late last week, the plan was to push H115 through to the House Insurance Committee, which is chaired by Rep. Jerry Dockham, the insurance broker who introduced it.

But we advocates got the word out about the bill, despite the reluctance of most of the state’s media to pay any attention to it, and filled the gallery. Without saying a word, we let them know the word is out and we will fight them on this.

The bill that was supposed to create the health exchange was being drafted by a diverse panel of experts including health care providers, advocates, consumers, physicans and more. The group was put together by the NC Institute of Medicine, and it met several times to turn a suggested federal bill into a framework that would work for the protection and benefit of people of North Carolina.

But the insurance companies wanted control. They wanted to be able to “pre-authorize the expensive diagnostic tests that drive up health care costs.”  Sounds reasonable enough, right?

Wrong. Last year, they forced my husband to wait two days for a nuclear stress test after a bad EKG, very nearly killing him.

They wanted to be able to “offer consumers a wide variety of plans from which to choose.”

Like the catostrophic plan a friend of mine chose with a $10,000 deductible. When she developed breast cancer, she was told her chemotherapy wouldn’t be covered because it was outpatient.

What they want is to be able to confuse people into buying something that covers little more than the insurance company’s butt.

Then they asked for a voting seat on the board of directors, and nearly everyone at the meeting said it would be a clear conflict of interest. A couple weeks later, H115 appeared, before the Institute of Medicine panel could finish its work, giving seven of the 11 seats to insurance companies, brokers and their allies, all of whom opposed reform.

This morning, committee chair, Rep. Bill Current (R-Gastonia), said he didn’t even know “why we’re bothering with this since Obamacare is unconstitutional anyway.”

Insurance Commissioner Wayne Goodwin told him it’s a good idea “just in case,” because if the Affordable Care Act isn’t unconstitutional, and North Carolina doesn’t have an exchange, the federal government would operate the exchange. Then he went on to make some proposals from what the IOM panel has worked on:

  • A seven-member board composed of people with technical expertise and no financial interest in the exchange. The board would be complemented by five advisory committees that would include insurance companies and consumers.
  • Compliance with open records and open meeting laws, something H115 lacks.

The committee decided to meet again to discuss the insurance exchange in two weeks, which gives advocates two more weeks to get the word out that health reform in North Carolina is in danger of being subverted by big business and big greed.

If we don’t stop the takeover here in North Carolina, other states will follow suit. If we do stop it, big insurance will be on notice that we’re watching and we intend to put a stop to their efforts.

Jobs are jobs

Here I am at last week's Solidarity rally in downtown Asheville

A Facebook friend posted a link to an article that said the public sector is shedding jobs at an alarming rate. My friend, like many other Americans, thought that was a good thing.

Get rid of public jobs and your taxes go down, right? The private sector can pick up the services and then we don’t have to pay those high wages and benefits, plus it’s more efficient.

Only if you think Halliburton and the other no-bid contractors have saved us money in Iraq and Afghanistan.

Public sector jobs are jobs. If you fire public workers, you have that many more unemployed.

The only reason the right is attacking public workers is because they haven’t been able to bust those unions yet.

Fewer than 10 percent of private-sector employees are members of a union, and those who are enjoy a lot fewer benefits than they once did.  Meanwhile, their employers are raking in the money hand over fist.

When you privatize public services, the union workers lose their jobs and are replaced with people making a whole lot less money and often receiving few, if any, benefits. Meanwhile costs for the same services go up. There’s less oversight, which is just what the right wants.

The average public worker only has better benefits than the average private-sector employee because of the protection of the unions. Their salaries average about the same as private-sector workers — they used to average a lot less, but the private sector has lost a lot of ground since Reagan took office and this mad dash to privitization began.

Government is not bad. It is the most efficient provider of services such as police, fire and military protection, social services, roads and other infrastructure, education and more. Get rid of or privatize those services and you’ll get lower quality for a lot more money.

This sin’t about affordability; there’s plenty to go around — it’s just that most of it is being hoarded by the top 2 percent.

We weren’t paying attention as the private-sector unions were dismantled; we need to  now.

Michael Moore does Wisconsin

Michael Moore brings it to wanker in his own backyard.

Who benefits from tort “reform?”

North Carolina legislators are trying to pass a tort reform bill that would make it very difficult for the average person to sue for malpractice and gain anything.

Here’s why: The cap on a human life would be $500,000. I know that sounds like a lot, but in terms of legal fees and whatnot, it’s really very small. The big insurance companies who represent doctors and hospitals have millions to spend on delaying the lawsuit until your lawyer and you have nothing left, so most lawyers won’t take the case.

I know this to be true because when my son, Mike,  died, attorneys in Georgia, where they already have tort “reform,” told me I had plenty of grounds for a lawsuit, but I’d be very lucky to find an attorney to take the case. Even if one would, neither of us would get anything after the hospitals’ and doctors’ insurance company attorneys were done with us.

Fortunately, Mike had asked me not to sue anyone and I agreed. I did ask the hospital for an apology for the way he was treated, but the medical ethics person told me I was asking for too much. It brought to mind the old Bea Arthur character, Maude, who used to say, “God’ll get you for that.” I had to walk away and do something positive.

The multi-million-dollar settlements some people get are rare — that’s why they make the news —  and most of those outrageous settlements are reduced on appeal. You don’t hear so much about that, though.

Mostly, tort “reform” is about taking away the ability of people to get any compensation when they have been wronged. It protects the health care industry from any consequences of their action (or inaction).

Most doctors and medical societies do want to see tort reform, but most don’t want to take it as far as the NC legislature does.

We the people are being attacked on all sides right now. Every day brings another assault on our rights, on our income, on our protections. I, for one, do not plan to give up, but it’s an uphill battle against these thugs.

The Right rams it through

On Tuesday, the NC House of Representatives will vote on H115, the bill that hands over control of the health insurance exchange to Big Insurance and their allies. I’m still hoping it can be stopped, but there hasn’t been much attention paid by the media, even though we advocates have tried and tried to call attention to it. The Raleigh News & Observer did a story, but there has been nothing out here in the western end of the state.

There’s also a bill to deny low-interest student loans to community college students, who often attend community college for financial reasons. These are people who may already work for a living and are trying to train for a job that will support them better. Kids who go to private universities are more often from families with the money to afford college.

Another bill would take money away from public schools to pay for charter and private schools. A voucher for private school tuition just takes money from public schools that already are underfunded. It won’t improve education; in fact, it likely will make public education worse.

The legislature is ramming through all sorts of bad legislation in its first 100 days, hoping to change the state to a place where being poor is seen as a moral failure of some sort.

They believe government jobs should be cut, but those jobs are real jobs. To cut them means putting people out of work where they will collect unemployment compensation instead of paying taxes. That seems to be more expensive to me.

In fact, a lot of the social changes the right wants to make will cost taxpayers money or make things even harder on working-class  and poor Americans. Let’s say you cut money for free clinics, so people lose their access to care. It costs more than three times as much to treat them in the emergency room, and the care is less comprehensive. Remember, the emergency room only has to stabilize patients — to address the symptoms, not necessarily the cause.

If Planned Parenthood is cut, where do poor women go for annual checkups, contraceptives and prenatal care? It’s very likely that more babies will die from neglect than ever did from abortion at Planned Parenthood.

Even in Wisconsin, where the flap is all about the power of public employees to negotiate with the state, there are draconian measures in the bill to cut services and cut public jobs.

This is not about the budget at all; this is about whether the middle class even survives, both figuratively and literally.

A piece of the cookie

Protests in Wisconsin have drawn tens of thousands, and sparked protests in cities nationwide.

I heard a great joke this morning: A corporate CEO, a Tea Party activist and a union representative are sitting at a table. In the middle is a plate with 12 cookies. The CEO reaches in and takes 11 of the cookies, then  turns to the Tea Party activist and says, “Watch out for that union guy; he’s about to take a piece of your cookie.”

It would be funnier of it weren’t so true. Right now, I see posts all over Facebook from friends who are fed up with the unions because of the abuses they’re suddenly hearing about.

This is the same thing the wealthy on the right did with health reform. They villify the Medicare system and other public and public-private hybrid systems around the world in an effort to make working people think any government involvement in health care would be a bad, bad, socialist, commie think to do.

What they don’t tell you is that our health system was rated 37th by the World Health Organization because so many poeople lack access to it. Our life expectancy is 19th in the world.

Now they’re doing it with unions. I noticed a couple of friends had a story about some kind of union “abuse” this morning, and I know it’s the same thing. They own so much of the media that it’s hard to get the word out that unions are the things that gave us weekends, 40-hour work weeks, AND access to health care through our jobs, at least until they began to be stripped of power.

That started with Ronald Reagan firing all the air-traffic controllers in the 1980s, stripping of them of the right to strike for better working conditions. At the newspaper where I worked at the time, all the “back shop” people — the ones who pasted up the paper and got it ready for printing — were firesd for striking. Years later, a court would reinstate them, but not with back pay.

Newspaper mogul Dean Singleton knew in 1985 that he could settle with the Teamsters Union and screw the rest of them. He was, and likely still is, very adept at union busting. Gannett, even though it didn’t have unions, was a good company to work for in 1986. People were treated pretty well so there would be no need for unions. That didn’t last. With no union to protect them, employees were asked to do more and more as their numbers decreased. In Asheville, about two-thirds of the employees of the Citizen-Times have been laid off in the last four years.

At the same time, unions in the private sector have become less and less powerful as employers like the Koch Brothers threated massive layoffs — or to move their entire operation to South America and lay everyone off — unless the unions capitulate to their demands.

Now they scream about how powerful the public unions are. Not so much as they used to be, but more than many private sector unions for hourly employees. In the 1950s through the 1970s, unions negotiated a living wage for people who worked. If you worked a full week, you made enough to live on and perhaps buy the products you made.

Reagan started the union-busting, and it has been very successful in the private sector. Now we have to defend the public employees’ unions so we can start to rebuild the private-sector unions.

Unions defend workers’ rights. They are not evil, they are essential.

We can’t let the right take away our rights with smear campaigns. When you see it, stand up for the unions. Stand strong. Don’t back down unless you want to go back to the days of the Industrial Revolution, before unions came to the defense of the workers.

It’s all connected

I'm here with Doug Wingier, a longtime social activist.

Jobs, Planed Parenthood,living wages,  health reform — it’s all the same issue, really.

Big business wants to get rid of the unions so they don’t have to pay benefits or decent wages.  Planned Parenthood provides basic health care to millions of women across the country. It prevents many more infant deaths than it causes by keeping women healthy. I got my care there before I had insurance; I couldn’t have afforded it otherwise.

Big corporations have sent jobs overseas because they don’t have to pay a living wage and no one in a developing country is going to make them.
And as long as the wealthiest Americans — the top 2 percent — can gain access to the best health care system in the world, it doesn’t matter to them how many of the rest of us are kept away.
Since these issues are so interconnected, our responses should be too.
With one hand, Gov. Scott Walker of Wisconsin is trying to take away union rights; with the other; he’s getting ready to yank Medicaid for another 65,000.
In North Carolina, Blue Cross Blue Shield is trying to take control of the Health Benefits Exchange so it can minimize protections for the 1 million

Not a bad idea -- because it's pretty much the same thing mine said.

consumers who will have to buy from the exchange.

At the same time, the state legislature has promised to leave classrooms alone.

Bridgett McCurry was at the Planned Parenthood support rally Saturday in Asheville. I was at both that one and the Solidarity rally

The plan is to divide and conquer, as though human rights wasn’t running through all of this mess. We can’t let that happen. We all need to be at every rally hollering about all these issues.

If they divide us into separate issues, we lose.
On Saturday there were two rallies in Asheville, one to support the workers in Wisconsin, which drew 400-500 people, and one to support Planned Parenthood, which drew over 100. A number of us went from the Solidarity rally to the other one, carrying our same signs and trying not to wave union signs at people honking in support of women’s health care. 
But the best idea I’ve seen yet is the Together NC rally. Together NC is a group of people affiliated with a wide variety of nonprofits and other agencies that tries to bring people together on all the issues that are being attacked by the right.
Last week, nearly 100 of us gathered in front of City Hall and the County Building and stood up for various causes. We stood together to support health care, education, disability rights, child abuse protection, racial justice and more.
We need to let them know we’re here to fight every kind of injustice and we’re not backing down.
 

Solidarity

I put on my old tie-dye shirt this morning so I can go to the solidarity rally downtown at noon.

We the people are being attacked on so many fronts it’s hard to know where to fight. The answer is we have to fight on all fronts and we have to be united.

Here in North Carolina, we don’t have the right of collective bargaining for public employees. I want things to move in the right direction in Wisconsin.

This is a “right-to-work” state, which means you really have no right to work. You can still be fired for being gay, or  or because the boss doesn’t ,like your face — or because you want to form a union.

For 30 years, big business and the politicians it owns have fought the unions, which are as important for organizing Democrats as the Koch Brothers and other fabulously wealthy business people are to the Republicans. If workers don’t have the union working for their interests, it’s easier to get people to vote against their own interests.

Unions in the private sector have been all but destroyed. Only 7 percent of workers belong to one.

Yes, they got corrupt at the top, but nowhere near as corrupt as Wall Street, and I don’t see that being busted up.

This is about taking power away from the people and consolidating it among only the wealthy. It is class warfare and it’s been going on since Ronald Reagan took office.

They say government is the problem, and it is for them. They don’t want anything interfering with their greed.

Fight the Big Blue power grab

Blue Cross Blue Shield of North Carolina, which has more than 80 percent of the health insurance market in the state, is trying to gain control of the insurance exchange that goes into effect in 2014 as part of the Affordable Care Act.

Each state must create an exchange of its own, collaborate with other states to create a larger exchange or allow the federal government to run an exchange. In North Carolina, more than a million people will buy their health insurance through the exchange once the law takes effect. It is meant to offer consumers a place where they can shop and compare among plans. The number of plans is supposed to be limited so people can compare.

The plan for North Carolina’s health exchange was to be developed by a work group set up by the NC Institute of Medicine. I have been at the meetings of this panel as an interested party, able to comment, but not to vote. The panel has people from all areas of health care, including physicians and members of the health insurance industry.

From the beginning, it was obvious they had a lot they were unhappy about:

  • They wanted to be able to sell an unlimited number of plans, which will only serve to confuse consumers. Many of them will only serve the insurance companies with their high deductible and low co-pays. This is how insurance companies deceive customers now, and many people don’t understand the fine print until they get sick and discover they can’t afford care because their deductible is $10,000 or even more, and much of what they need isn’t covered at all.
  • Insurance companies wanted no standardization of plans so consumers can’t compare apples to apples.
  • Of the 15 companies doing business in North Carolina, 14 have asked for a waiver of the 80 percent rule which forces them to spend 80 percent of the money they receive in premiums on services. Medicaid spends 97 percent of the money it takes in on services. That’s because they don’t have to pay lobbyists, public relations executives and huge executive salaries and bonuses.
  • They didn’t want regulation of rates and they didn’t want any company to be thrown out of the exchange for excessive rate hikes — or any other reason, for that matter.
  • The insurance companies asked for voting seats on the exchange’s board of directors, allowing them to regulate themselves. At the meeting they raised that point, nearly everyone spoke out against it.

Soon after the meeting, a panel member who was an insurance company representative sent out a letter resigning from the panel because everyone was prejudiced against the poor insurance companies, who are only in business to help people, after all.

My thought was, “you do have a history, you know.”

So, they went and wrote their own bill and had it introduced by a friendly state representative in the NC House as House Bill 115. The bill gives insurance companies and their allies, all of whom opposed reform, seven of the 11 seats on the board.

They’ve been able to do this quietly because the media aren’t interested in the story, which is all the more reason you should be.

If this bill passes the house and senate in North Carolina, consumers will see no benefits from reform; it will have been destroyed from the inside.

To be fair, BCBS claims it didn’t write the bill, but it backs it wholeheartedly.

Another bill has been introduced, House Bill 126, that is pretty close to what the panel was backing. It has gotten no attention at all. H126 would leave insurance companies as advisors, which is the right way to do it.

As a health care advocate who has been involved in the process, I feel like we’ve been played like a cheap violin. We negotiated in good faith while they were just biding their time until this dangerous bill could be introduced.

Both houses of the NC General Assembly have big Republican majorities, and this is being played out here while the rest of the country is distracted by the labor issues and the unrest in the Middle East.

Other states’ insurance companies will follow suit. Health care reform will be destroyed from the inside and consumers will be forced to buy insurance from companies who are “regulating” themselves.

We must make a stand here, even as labor makes a stand in Wisconsin. The attacks on labor, health care, education and social justice in general are coming fast and hard, and if we don’t fight back, we lose big time.